UPS:
In E-Commerce We Trust
As United Parcel Service stepped into the secure-electronic-data-transmission
business this week, it promised to make online-document delivery
as trustworthy and easy to use as a dollar bill minted by the
US Treasury.
"We view ourselves as a trusted third party," said
Mark Rhoney, vice president of marketing for electronic commerce
at UPS.
What UPS will offer by the second quarter of 1998 is an alternative
to the encryption model offered by companies like Entrust
Technologies and Network Associates' PGP
division.
Entrust and PGP hawk encryption systems that allow one person
to send a secure data file to someone else with no meddling from
any outsiders. UPS's new service, developed in partnerships with
Tumbleweed
Software and NetDox, is based on the idea that a supervisor
should be involved in the process to guarantee the integrity of
the information being sent.
Say a lawyer wants to send a contract worth US$3 million, but
the recipient decides to tinker with the numbers and knock the
figure down to $2.5 million. The situation dissolves to finger
pointing, each side saying they agreed to something different.
With the UPS system, the data that is sent will be digitally
fingerprinted and archived with time stamps and receipts from
each party, so there will be records of whether or not a document
has been tampered with.
"The document is digitally notarized and legally binding,"
said NetDox spokesman Lee Kallman. If there is a finger-pointing
situation, UPS will be able to prove in court exactly what was
sent, by whom, who received it, and when.
"That's what you don't get with other encryption systems,
and that's the void [UPS] wants to fill," said Kallman. The
service will play a role not unlike the role a government plays
when it guarantees the value of currency, Kallman said.
UPS will insure the integrity of each document, and the identity
of both sender and receiver, for up to US$100,000.
The system is called UPS Document Exchange, and it will offer
two levels of security - Dossier for the strong stuff and Courier
for the milder version.
For the most sensitive data, UPS will use a system designed by
NetDox that requires users to download a software client that
wraps data - any sort of digital information, from simple documents
to multimedia - in two layers of encryption, an inner 40-bit layer,
and an outer 128-bit layer. The data is sent to a UPS server where
it is unwrapped, and a digital fingerprint is taken and stored;
then it is re-wrapped and sent to its destination, where the recipient
opens it with the NetDox client software.
For less-critical data packages, UPS will use a system designed
by Tumbleweed that encrypts data with a varying number of bits
to accommodate the different encryption levels supported by browsers
in different countries. The encrypted data is then sent to a UPS
server, where it is stored at a 128-bit encryption level. The
server sends an email message to the recipient telling him or
her the Web address where the data resides and how it can be accessed
via browser with RSA encryption.
UPS has been close-mouthed on the question of price, saying only
that delivery will be more expensive than a 32-cent stamp and
cheaper than a traditional overnight delivery.
NetDox has been charging $5.35 for domestic transactions and
$10.70 for international data exchanges, according to Kallman.
But it hasn't had much competition. If the UPS service proves
viable and other competitors emerge, prices could drop precipitously,
Kallman said.
News of the UPS service was greeted warmly in some corners of
the encryption industry, and skeptically in others.
"We're very excited to hear that a large company like UPS
is rolling out a broad-based service like this," said Gina
Klein Jorasch, director of enterprise marketing at VeriSign.
The company provides digital certificates, which act like identity
cards tying a user's identity to a public key that enables the
encryption process.
VeriSign has reason to be hopeful, though. Software clients like
the ones provided by NetDox and Tumbleweed require digital certificates,
just like those provided by VeriSign. "A deal between VeriSign
and UPS is very conceivable," Jorasch said.
Jeff Harell, the product manager for PGP products at Network
Associates, quarreled with the fundamental idea of involving outsiders
in the data transmission process.
"Why would a corporate customer want to go to third-party
[systems]?" Harell asked. "A lot of companies don't
want to involve a third party that they are required to trust."
Many companies view their data as too important to risk exposing
to a system with so many junctions and exchange points.
PGP is a proprietary system. Users sending and receiving data
must both have PGP, and their keys can only be provided and verified
by PGP.
All of this is new in the traditional package delivery industry,
but not unexpected.
"Now that the Web has become so ubiquitous, this strikes
me as something that UPS and the other delivery companies needed
to do," said Rita Knox, an industry analyst with the Gartner
Group.
"This is a pretty compelling service," Knox added.
"It's available 24/7 and it's virtually instantaneous."
Federal Express, after a failed attempt to introduce an electronic
service in the early 1980s, ended up setting a standard in the
industry in 1995 when it launched a self-service ordering and
tracking system on the Web.
Similar services have since been adopted by UPS and Airborne
Express, among other competitors. Analysts are looking ahead to
the possibility of UPS’s online delivery service becoming an industry
must-have if it proves successful.
"I definitely anticipate another domino effect if UPS has
any success with this at all," said Michael Sullivan-Trainer
of International Data Corp. "All it takes is one competitor
to introduce a new software innovation and it changes industry
dynamics."
by
Randolph Court
|